Three worked examples
These examples are calculated by the same engine as the tool. Expand a solution to follow every step.
Solve x² + 10x = 39 for the positive length x.
- Split 10x into two strips of width 5.
- The missing corner is 5² = 25.
- New area: 39 + 25 = 64.
- Side length: √64 = 8.
- Remove the added 5: x = 3.
Answer: 3
Solve x² + 10x = 96 for the positive length x.
- Split 10x into two strips of width 5.
- The missing corner is 5² = 25.
- New area: 96 + 25 = 121.
- Side length: √121 = 11.
- Remove the added 5: x = 6.
Answer: 6
Solve x² + 10x = 39 for the positive length x.
- Split 10x into two strips of width 5.
- The missing corner is 5² = 25.
- New area: 39 + 25 = 64.
- Side length: √64 = 8.
- Remove the added 5: x = 3.
Answer: 3
Read the history through surviving evidence
Al-Khwarizmi wrote his algebra in Abbasid Baghdad in the early ninth century. The Library of Congress describes a work intended for practical calculation, including trade, inheritance and surveying. Its Arabic title contains al-jabr, from which algebra takes its name. [1] These facts give the lesson a setting; they do not make every algebraic idea the invention of one scholar. The useful question here is how a particular explanation turns an unknown area into a known length.
A surviving manuscript can also change how we read the lesson. Oxford’s Digital Bodleian provides MS. Huntington 214, a witness to the text rather than a modern exercise sheet. [2] Our draggable shapes, letter x and equals signs are teaching choices. Treat the diagram as a way to understand a mathematical argument associated with the work, and avoid imagining that its exact interface or notation appeared in the historical book.
Identify what each quantity measures
The central shape has side length x, so its area is x². Each attached strip has one side x and one side k, giving area kx. Together the strips contribute 2kx. The known quantity c therefore represents an area, not the side of the central square. Before calculating, point to the central square, both strips and the absent corner. Naming those four regions prevents most confusion later.
The constant k is half the coefficient attached to x. It measures a strip’s width. The little missing corner has width k and height k, so it has area k². This is why the instruction is to square the half-coefficient: it comes from the dimensions of a real region in the model. A coefficient, a length and an area play different roles even when they are represented by ordinary numbers.
Follow the argument in a reliable order
Begin with the stated total area x² + 2kx = c. Split the combined rectangular contribution into two equal strips. Arrange one along the bottom and one along the side of the central square. Their outside edges make almost a square of side x + k. Add the missing corner of area k². The completed area is now c + k², because you have added exactly that amount to the original collection of regions.
Find the positive square root of the completed area. That gives x + k, the entire outside side. Finally subtract k to recover x. In the activity, enter each requested intermediate quantity under its matching label: missing corner area, completed square area, completed side, and positive length. The displayed examples calculate their own values, so use the explanation to decide which operation comes next instead of memorising one set of numbers.
Explain why the construction preserves the problem
No region disappears when the pieces are rearranged. Moving a strip changes its position, while preserving its dimensions and area. Adding the corner does change the total, and that change is recorded on the right side of the equation. The resulting statement is (x + k)² = c + k². Expanding its left side returns x² + 2kx + k², which confirms the geometric bookkeeping.
The method separates two tasks that often become mixed together: accounting for area and recovering a length. First complete an area accurately; only then take a square root. Taking a square root earlier would not separate the sum into useful pieces. In particular, the square root of a sum is generally different from the sum of its square roots. The complete outer square is what makes the root meaningful.
Keep the positive-length model in view
This puzzle asks for a positive length, so x and k describe positive distances. The completed side is therefore the positive square root. A modern equation with unrestricted real x requires another check: from (x + k)² = c + k², algebra permits x + k to be either square root when the completed area is positive. The negative branch gives a negative x for the positive constants used here.
That second algebraic answer does not fit the drawn central square, because a square’s side is not a negative physical length. Both statements can be correct: the unrestricted equation has two real roots, and the particular geometric question accepts one positive length. Always read what the unknown represents before deciding how many answers to report. A diagram provides a domain, not a licence to discard roots in every quadratic problem.
Common mistakes
- Using the full linear coefficient for the corner. The two strips share the linear contribution. Their common width is half the coefficient of x, so square that half to find the corner area.
- Reporting the completed outside side as x. The square root gives x + k. Remove one strip width after finding that root to recover the central square’s side.
- Making the historical diagram universal. This model uses positive lengths and modern notation. It illustrates a particular argument, and it does not reproduce every equation type in the historical treatise.
Questions learners ask
Did al-Khwarizmi write equations with x?
The lesson’s symbolic equation is a modern rendering. His explanations used words; compare the historical text witness with the diagram rather than assuming today’s notation was present. [2]
Why do I add an area instead of a length?
The original equation totals areas. The missing corner contributes k² square units. Its side k is used later when recovering the length x.
Must every completed area be a perfect square?
No. The reasoning also works with irrational square roots. This introductory activity chooses values that make the positive side convenient to calculate.
Why is a negative root absent from the drawing?
The unknown is a positive physical length. A negative algebraic root can satisfy the unrestricted equation while falling outside that geometric interpretation.
Keep learning
Connect this method to the main Math learning path:
Sources and historical scope
A modern positive-length reconstruction associated with al-Khwarizmi’s algebra, with no claim of exclusive invention or historical symbolic notation.
- Library of Congress — The Compendious Book on Calculation by Completion and Balancing ↗
- Digital Bodleian — MS. Huntington 214 ↗
The diagrams, examples and printable questions on this page are newly created teaching material. Historical context comes from the sources above.